What’s Next? A Correction, Not a Bear Market, Says Stovall

The sinking stock market did a remarkable turnaround Monday, with the S&P 500 shifting from a 4% tumble to finish up 0.3%. But many Wall Street observers, such as Morgan Stanley’s chief US equity strategist, Mike Wilson, think it will fall even more.

OK, then how low can it go? That’s the question that Sam Stovall, CFRA’s chief investment strategist, asked in a research note. No more than 10%, which is the definition of a correction, he wrote.

Consulting market history, Stovall said the index has always had a market decline in the calendar year following an annual gain of 20% or more. That sure fits right now. The S&P 500 rose just under 27% in 2021. Further, all first-half slides were transformed later into a full recovery, returning the market to its starting point, he found. Plus, he added, the average drop from first-half selloffs was 10%, no more.

“In the end, history says (but does not guarantee) that the S&P 500 will likely join the Nasdaq in correction territory before its P/E gets trimmed to a more realistic level,” Stovall admonished, referring to the price/earnings ratio.

Never miss a story — sign up for CIO newsletters to stay up-to-date on the latest institutional investment industry news. 

Stovall also partly conducted his analysis using market technicians’ methodologies, specifically Fibonacci retracement levels (FRLs), which are percentage declines based on the advance from an important low.

Using the recent low from the pandemic’s outset, March 23, 2020, of 2,237, the index climbed all the way to the Jan. 3, 2022, high of 4,797. And by technicians’ figuring, that “points to an impending decline to the 4,193 level for a peak-to-trough tumble of 12.6%,” Stovall stated. That, in turn, “would place it squarely in the correction camp,” he concluded.

The CFR strategist also calculated that, if the market kept on falling, the logic of FRLs dictated that it would reach “a mild bear market” of minus 20.4%. Other levels below that were 33.0% and 53.4%. But Stovall didn’t seem to believe that things would get that bad.

“We think the coming week’s market action will be very telling as to the severity of the overall decline,” he wrote.