The 9 Firms Most Exposed to Risky Multiemployer Pensions

A list, courtesy of ratings agency Fitch.

(August 13, 2012) – Rating agency Fitch is concerned about the risks of multiemployer pension plans (MEPP) to participating companies’ solvency, and has calculated the nine firms most exposed to these typically “significantly underfunded” plans.  

And they sent aiCIO the list. 

1. Safeway Inc. 

2. Supervalu Inc. 

Want the latest institutional investment industry
news and insights? Sign up for CIO newsletters.

3. Kroger Co. 

4. Harsco Corporation 

5. Dean Foods Company 

6. Rite Aid Corporation 

7. News Corporation 

8. US Airways Group Inc. 

9. Del Monte Group 

With multiemployer pension plans, participating companies and their employees bear the risk of investment losses despite having limited control over plan administration and investment decisions. Fitch’s report further noted that “when a participating employer files for Chapter 11 or liquidates, that employer’s share of the funding shortfall would land on the remaining employers in the plan to the extent it is not recovered in the courts.” 

Fitch’s issuer default ratings for these companies range from decent to marginal, with Dean Foods and Del Monte pulling passable Bs, and Supervalue bringing up the rear with a CCC. 

The ratings agency is watching MEPP exposure closely as they periodically adjust their ratings. “Fitch does not expect any near-term rating actions resulting from MEPP liabilities,” the report said. “However, growth in MEPP contributions due to funding shortfalls, which can be exacerbated by employer insolvencies, could result in further downward pressure on supermarket EBIT margins, which have already narrowed significantly in recent years, and, over time, lead to rating downgrades.”

Preqin: Majority of Institutional Investors Bullish on Private Equity

A total of 65% of institutional investors expect private equities will deliver returns at least 4% over public markets, according to a new survey from data provider Preqin.

(August 13, 2012) – Most (71%) of institutional investors are satisfied with returns on private equity investments, and 99% expect returns will beat public markets, according to a recent Preqin survey of over 100 investors. 

With higher fees and reduced transparency, private equity investments have to not only outperform public equities, but by a substantial margin. And 65% of the pension, foundation and endowment investors surveyed anticipate their private equity allocations will beat the public market by at least 400 basis points. 

“[We] have had our ups and downs with private equity, but on the whole and over the longer term, [private equity returns] have met expectations,” said one US public pension fund respondent. 

Almost half (49%) of those surveyed intend to both commit capital with existing fund managers and invest with managers they haven’t worked with in the past. Small to medium-sized buyout funds are the most popular fund type, with 49% of investors saying they will offer the best opportunities over the next 12 months. The same portion of respondents expect to commit capital to modestly sized buyout funds by summer 2013. Venture capital is the next most popular, with 23% of investors foreseeing best-in-class returns from that fund type. 

Want the latest institutional investment industry
news and insights? Sign up for CIO newsletters.

The survey also found substantial appetite for emerging markets: 68.4% of institutional investors said they expect to increase their exposure to these markets in the next 12 months. Among established markets, North America was looked on most favorably, and 24% of respondents won’t even consider investing in Europe. Still, Preqin found some investors are seeing opportunity lurking in the Continent’s precarious economy. 

“Despite the financial crisis, Europe is presenting some strong investment opportunities if there is a real strong long-term strategy,” said one respondent from an American endowment.

«