Pennsylvania Pension Panel Looks to Cut Investment Managers’ Fees

Study group searches for ways to bridge shortfall in state workers’ and teachers’ plans. 

Looking to narrow the funding gap for two of its largest state pension funds, a Pennsylvania study commission is eyeing a reduction in the fees outside investment managers receive.

The two funds, the $29.4 billion State Employees’ Retirement System and the $58 billion Public School Employees’ Retirement System have between $66 billion and $89 billion in pension obligations. Overall, Pennsylvania’s retirement system is 53% funded.

Led by Republican state Rep. Mike Tobash and Democratic state Treasurer Joe Torsella, the Public Pension Management and Asset Investment Review Commission held its first hearing to explore how to narrow the funding shortfall.  The goal is to save each plan $1.5 billion in annual costs over 30 years.

Since 2008, Torsella estimates the state spent $5.5 billion on management fees for high-risk funds that flopped.

Never miss a story — sign up for CIO newsletters to stay up-to-date on the latest institutional investment industry news.

“If you can’t measure it, you can’t manage it,” he said, according to WHYY.org. “And if you don’t know what it is, then you don’t know if the interests of the beneficiaries of the plan and the taxpayers are aligned with the interests of the managers.”

Tobash wants the two pension funds to look at their positions in high-cost investments and make changes in allocations to drive down costs.

Neither returned requests for comment.

The commission was established last year to review the investment decisions of the two pension systems.  Already, as a result of their findings, the state is shifting a hybrid 401(k)-style plan for new hires and also has a buffer to protect taxpayers from increases if investment targets are not met. Plus, the retirement age will also increase next year to 67 from 65.

The group has six months to finish its review of the retirement funds. As part of its evaluation, it will suggest improvements to stress testing and fee transparency for the school plans. The commission will also analyze assets, investment strategies, performance, fees, and costs against established benchmarks.

The Pennsylvania pension and asset management group will hold two more hearings later in the year. Those will focus on analyzing the two school pensions across various areas, which include asset allocation, fees, costs, performance, and processes.

Tags: , , , ,

CIO’s Ninth Annual Industry Innovation Awards: Last Days to Nominate!

Nominations for innovative and talented asset owners and managers/servicers open until August 4.

It’s time again to nominate and celebrate the industry’s most innovative asset owners and managers/servicers. CIO’s ninth annual Industry Innovation Awards will take place December 13 at the New York Public Library, celebrating the most innovative and talented players of institutional investing.

Please nominate asset owners and managers/servicers for this year’s awards via our digital survey or by filling out our 2018 CIO nominations form and emailing your nominations to CIOeditors@strategic-i.comNominations will close August 4, and all finalists will be announced in early September. 

For more stories like this, sign up for the CIO Alert newsletter.

This year, the CIO editorial team will consult an advisory board of former and current chief investment officers, including Raphael Arndt, CIO of Australia’s Future Fund; Jagdeep Singh Bachher, CIO, vice president of Investments, University of California; Matt Clark, CIO, South Dakota Investment Council; Scott Evans, CIO of the New York City Pension Funds; David Holmgren, CIO of Hartford HealthCare; Tom Joy, CIO, Church of England; Kim Lew, CIO, Carnegie Corporation of New York; Richard Nuzum, president of Mercer’s global wealth business (2017 Consultant of the Year); and Bob Watson, CIO of FCA US. Some categories, such as investment outsourcing, transition management, and corporate investment strategies, will be judged largely on data collected via the CIO survey system.

The lifetime achievement award, which Ashbel C. “Ash” Williams, executive director and CIO of the Florida State Board of Administration (SBA), won last year, will be presented at the dinner. An overall winner from the asset owner categories will also be chosen and awarded CIO of the Year (presented last year to Evans).

Our Next Generation Award is chosen the evening of the awards dinner, following a panel at the CIO Influential Investors’ Forum.

This year’s asset owner categories include (2017 winners in parentheses): 

Foundation (Carnegie Foundation, Kim Lew)

Endowment (Church Commissioners for England, Tom Joy)

Corporate Defined Benefit Pension Plan Below $5 Billion (Computer Sciences – CSRA Inc., Brian Reed)

Corporate Defined Benefit Pension Plan Above $5 Billion (ABB,Elisabeth Bourqui)

Public Defined Benefit Plan Below $15 Billion (South Dakota Investment Council, Matt Clark)

Public Defined Benefit Plan Between $15 Billion and $100 Billion (Hawaii Employees’ Retirement System, Vijoy Chattergy)

Public Defined Benefit Plan Above $100 Billion (NYC Retirement System, Scott Evans)

Sovereign Wealth Fund (Australian Future Fund, Raphael Arndt)

Healthcare Organization (Hartford HealthCare, David Holmgren)

Defined Contribution Plan (Fiat Chrysler FCA US,Bob Watson)

ESG(University of California Regents, Jagdeep Singh Bachher)

Next Generation (W.K. Kellogg Foundation, Carlos Rangel)
Consulting (Mercer,Rich Nuzum)

*New 2018 Category: Collaboration

Asset management categories include (2017 winners in parentheses; italics indicate altered category): 

Fixed Income (Nuveen Asset Management)

Equities (including alternative equity beta) (BlackRock)

Multi-Asset (including risk-balanced strategies) (Neuberger Berman)

Private Equity (Apollo Global Management)

Hedge Funds (Citadel)

Real Assets (AEW Global)

Defined Contribution Strategies (Prudential)

Investment Outsourcing (Russell Investments)

Corporate Investment Strategies (includes the overall criteria to helpcorporate CIOs achieve their goals including positioning for growth, innovation in risk management, and hedging overall portfolios.) 

(Legal & General Investment Management America)

Transition Management (BlackRock)

Data & Technology (FactSet)

ESG Investing (Generation Investment Management)

*New 2018 Category: Emerging Markets

*New 2018 Category: Corporate LDI Strategies

Tags: ,

«