Group to Trump: Ax Investments in Indexes with Chinese Companies

An advocacy group is urging President Donald Trump to cancel anticipated investments from the federal Thrift Savings Plan (TSP) into the MSCI All-Country World Index, which would indirectly fund Chinese state-owned companies, the organization alleges.

The MSCI index has 6% of its portfolio invested in the stocks of corporations based in China, according to a statement from the Committee on the Present Danger: China. The Federal Retirement Thrift Investment Board voted to “mirror” this particular MSCI index starting next year.

The group finds this action unacceptable due to national security concerns connected with funding state-owned Chinese companies linked to the country’s Communist Party.

By funding such companies, the committee argues, the investments are “enabling Beijing to: violate US sanctions; illegally build and militarily fortify islands in the South China Sea; monitor, incarcerate, and repress its own and other nations’ religious minorities and ordinary citizens; engage in surveillance state practices, digital totalitarianism and “social credit” scoring; conduct cyberattacks and intellectual property theft; and construct advanced weapon systems with which to inflict murderous damage on this country and its men and women in uniform.”

Want the latest institutional investment industry news and insights? Sign up for CIO newsletters. 

Bipartisan legislation was recently introduced that would prohibit the TSP from following through with the MSCI Index investment. “America’s investors should never be a source of wealth funding Beijing’s rise at the expense of our nation’s future prosperity,” Senator Marco Rubio, a Florida Republican, one of the sponsors of the legislation, said in a statement.

“It is totally unacceptable for our veterans and those serving in uniform today to invest in Chinese companies building weapons designed to kill them or their comrades-in-arms,” the group said.

Critics of such opinion argue that across-the-board portfolio limits on investing in Chinese firms will harm the US.

“I would be much more comfortable with the US blocking the Thrift board from investing in particular entities that may be complicit in a human rights violation or that has stolen technology rather than saying the Thrift board can’t invest in China,” said Derek Scissors, a China expert at the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), the governing body of one of the biggest federal worker retirement programs. “The US government shouldn’t be involved in across-the-board bans.”

According to Bloomberg, the Trump administration wants to force stock indices to drop firms that the administration considers a material risk to US investors.

Endowments and Foundations Sticking It Out with China

Retirement Funds Are in the Crosshairs of US-China Conflict

Tags: China, communist, Donald Trump, federal pension, msci index, national security, thrift savings board

Saudi Arabia is in the throes of a fiscal crisis that is leading the country on a search for new revenue, including an upcoming initial public offering for Aramco, its sovereign oil company, former CIA chief David Petraeus told CNBC.

The kingdom, said Petraeus, who commanded troops in the Middle East as a US Army general, is going broke due to weak oil prices, so an IPO of Aramco stock is a lifeline. “It’s a fact that Saudi Arabia is gradually running out of money, they’d be the first to acknowledge that the sovereign wealth fund has been reduced,” he said. “The deficits each year, depending on the price of Brent crude, can be anywhere from $40 [billion] to $60 billion depending on some of their activities in countries in the region.”

Another fiscal drain, he noted, is the Saudis’ ambitious development plan, which the Aramco IPO proceeds would help fund. “The bottom line is that they need the money, they need that outside investment that is crucial to delivering Vision 2030, which cannot be realized without outside investment.”

The Vision 2030 program, launched in 2017, seeks to boost Saudi Arabia’s economy with non-oil revenue. The decline in oil prices has led to a financial crunch for the country. With Brent crude oil at $62 a barrel, the kingdom needs to fill the revenue gap that opened since the heyday of $100 a barrel petroleum and the emergence of other oil markets. In 2018, the budget deficit was about 136 riyals (around $36 billion) or 4.6% of GDP. In 2019, the estimated deficit is 131 riyals (around $35 billion) or 4.7% of GDP. Next year, it is projected to widen to 187 riyals (around $49 billion) or 6.5% of GDP.

For more stories like this, sign up for the CIO Alert newsletter. 

Investors are lining up for the IPO of Aramco in December. The IPO is expected to generate anywhere from $40 billion to $100 billion. Nine US banks are underwriting it. Countries from Brazil to China have expressed interest. RDIF, Russia’s sovereign wealth fund, is reportedly enlisting pension funds to get in on the action. Cash generated from the IPO will go to Saudi Arabia’s sovereign wealth fund, which owns the majority stake of Aramco. Valuations of Aramco range from $1.2 trillion to $2.3 trillion.

The Sovereign Wealth Fund Institute estimates that the current assets of Saudi Arabia’s Public Investment Fund are valued at $320 billion. The fund is invested in US firms through its $100 billion SoftBank Vision Fund. One of the mandates of the 47-year-old fund is to help the Saudi economy transition to less oil dependency.

Some of the funds’ investments center on autos, whether gasoline-powered or not. In 2016, the fund poured $3.5 billion into Uber, and took a 5% stake and a seat on its board of directors, which was filled by Yasir al-Rumayyan, managing director of the fund. This week, it invested $400 million into former Uber CEO Travis Kalanick’s new company, CloudKitchens. In August, the fund invested $1 billion in Lucid Motors, an electric auto startup. Earlier this year, the fund purchased a $2 billion stake in Tesla and a $461 million stake in Magic Leap, an augmented reality startup.

Saudi Arabia Sets Forth “Vision 2030” Economic Reform Agenda

Will Saudi Arabia Be Next on MSCI Emerging Market Index?

Tags: Aramco, IPO, Public Investment Fund, Saudi Arabia