Forget US Stocks and Head Overseas, BCA Says

Domestic stocks are now too hot to handle. That’s the conclusion of a BCA Research report, which found that US stocks are “looking pricey,” but there are some real bargains abroad. Wise investors will head offshore instead of sticking around with overbought US shares, the firm advises.

Using the Shiller price/earnings (P/E) ratio, BCA chief investment strategist Peter Berezin and his team found that “valuations outside the US are more reasonable.” To its adherents, the Shiller multiple, named after Yale economist Robert Shiller, is a better gauge than the common metric, which uses 12 months trailing earnings. The Shiller version covers 10 years of past earnings and adjusts for inflation.

US stocks trade at a Shiller P/E ratio of 37, but non-US stocks change hands at a ratio of only 20, Berezin found.

The non-Shiller P/E is 25.6 for the S&P 500, which has a good performance over the past 12 months of just under 25.5%, although thus far in the new year it is down 3.5% amid concerns about the coronavirus and inflation.

Want the latest institutional investment industry news and insights? Sign up for CIO newsletters. 

BCA is not alone in its enthusiasm for non-US stocks. Fidelity Investments, in the fund colossus’ look-ahead analysis, expects international stocks to outpace US equities over the next 20 years. Fidelity researchers wrote that “many international stocks represent relative bargains, which suggests they may offer opportunities for attractive returns as well as providing diversification for US investors’ portfolios.”

In fact, Morgan Stanley believes American stocks will finish this year 5% lower than 2021’s showing, while European and Japanese shares will power ahead. Europe’s stock will be up 8% and Japan’s ahead 12%, the firm projects.

“The persistent price outperformance of US stocks for much of the last decade has been driven by superior and more durable earnings trends,” said Mike Wilson, Morgan Stanley chief US equity strategist. “But uncertainties are mounting around cost pressures, supply issues, policy uncertainty, and tax changes.”

Indeed, there are bargains a-plenty beyond American soil. Take neighboring Mexico, whose stock index over the past 12 months is up 20.7% and ahead 0.9% in 2022. Its regular trailing P/E stands at 15.8. Mexican investments are benefiting from post-pandemic demand from US consumers, plus buoyant oil prices.

In Britain, which has had many economic woes from Brexit to an Omicron surge, the FTSE 100 is ahead 17% since mid-January 2021 (and off 3.1% this year), with a P/E of 18.2.

Germany, the industrial powerhouse of Europe, is thought to be in a good economic position once the pandemic recedes. Its DAX index is slightly in the red this year after a 15.6% return for the previous 12 months. P/E ratio: 15.4.

Japan’s economic recovery from the pandemic slowdown may finally be underway, analysts say. Its Nikkei 225 scored just a 2% increase over the past 12 months and is down 1.6% this year. The P/E is an affordable 16.1.

Beset by COVID-19 troubles that have put some economic activity in lockdown, China may see its vaunted growth engine sputter somewhat going forward. Goldman Sachs recently sliced the nation’s gross domestic product (GDP) forecast for 2022 to 4.3% from 4.8%. The hope is that the Beijing regime will crank up the stimulus in time for next fall’s Communist Party conclave, where President Xi Jinping seeks a third term.

On the stock front, China’s Shanghai Composite has eked out a mere 0.6% advance over the past 12 months, and is in the red 2.7% for 2022. The P/E is 15.1.

In all of these cases, foreign shares are cheaper than those in the US and, if the economic gods allow, may chart decent courses in 2022 to justify their purchase.