Endowment Index Ends Second Straight Year at Record High

Despite 10.14% rise during 2020, the index still underperformed a 60/40 stock-bond portfolio.


The Endowment Index calculated by Nasdaq OMX rose 10.14% to 1,517.54 in 2020 to end a second straight year with a record high. However, the index still underperformed a global portfolio of 60% equities and 40% fixed income, which returned 13.77% during the year.

Not surprisingly, the index had a rough start to the year as the COVID-19 pandemic exploded during the first quarter and sent global stock markets crashing. As a result of the global asset sell-off, the index tumbled to 987.70 on March 23. But, from that point, the index soared nearly 54% during the remainder of the year.

The strong investment returns were attributed to world governments’ unprecedented response to the pandemic, including massive monetary and fiscal stimulus and a concerted global effort to develop a vaccine for COVID-19. These efforts restored investor confidence and global markets began to rebound strongly.

The index represents the investable opportunity for managers of portfolios using the ETF Model Solutions’ Endowment Investment Philosophy or who incorporate alternative investments within a comprehensive asset allocation. The index measures performance for a multi-asset, globally diversified portfolio, and applies an objective construction methodology based on portfolio allocation data from more than 770 educational institutions. Each of the index’s 24 sub-indexes are investable and have more than 44,000 underlying securities.

Want the latest institutional investment industry
news and insights? Sign up for CIO newsletters.

Of the 24 components of the index, 19 saw gains for 2020 with 10 posting double-digit returns. They were led by emerging market equity–China, which surged 37.42%, followed by metals and mining, and gold, which increased 26.97% and 23.86%, respectively. US equity assets closed the year up 20.95%, while emerging markets, and commodity–timber gained 18.18% and 18.11%, respectively.

Other asset classes with double-digit gains for the year included global equities (16.74%), commodity–private agriculture (14.73%), private equity/venture capital (VC) (13.34%), and US Treasury inflation-protected securities (TIPS) (10.94%).

At the opposite end, the worst performing asset classes were commodity–oil and gas, and publicly traded master limited partnerships, which tanked 32.75% and 32.39%, respectively, during the year, followed by commodity/dividend-futures, which fell 11.64%. The only other asset classes to post losses for the year were international real estate and domestic real estate, which declined 6.87% and 4.72%, respectively.

Although it didn’t beat a 60/40 portfolio, the Endowment Index easily outperformed the aggregate performance of the Ivy League’s endowments, which collectively returned 6.3% for fiscal year 2020. It also surpassed each Ivy League endowment, except for Brown University’s endowment.

2020 Endowment Index Constituent Asset Class Performance

Asset Class

2020
Change
(%)

Asset Class

2020
Change
(%)

Em. Market Equity – China

37.42

Private Eq-Distressed Debt

6.38

Commodity – Met/Mining

26.97

Hedge Funds

5.56

Gold

23.86

Emerging Mkt Fixed Inc

5.48

US Equity

20.95

Intl Developed Fixed Inc

4.60

Emerging Markets

18.18

Commodity -Natural Resources

0.73

Commodity – Timber

18.11

Liquidity – TBills

0.39

Global Equities

16.74

Managed Futures

0.37

Commodity – Pvt. Agriculture

14.73

Domestic Real Estate

-4.72

Private Equity/VC

13.34

Intl. Real Estate

-6.87

US TIPS

10.94

Commodity/Div-Futures

-11.64

Intl Developed Equity

8.55

Publicly Traded MLP’s

-32.39

Domestic Fixed Inc.

7.71

Commodity – Oil & Gas

-32.75


Related Stories:

Ivy League Endowments Underperform 60-40 Portfolio Again

Endowment Index Returns Over 5% in Q3

Brown’s Endowment Is Killing It

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

VC Firm CEO Gets Six Years in Prison for Ponzi Scheme

David Wagner solicited nearly $10 million and used investor funds to buy a Porsche and pay earlier investors.


The CEO of a purported venture capital (VC) firm has been sentenced to six years in prison for securities fraud and wire fraud in connection with operating several corporate entities as a Ponzi-like scheme.

David Wagner, CEO of venture capital firm Downing, had previously pleaded guilty to soliciting nearly $10 million from approximately 40 investors through materially false and misleading statements. Wagner used a significant portion of those funds to pay management fees, repay prior investors, and pay for personal expenses, including a Porsche.

According to the indictment filed with the Southern District of New York, Wagner and co-defendant Marc Lawrence, who was the president of several Downing entities, solicited investments in Downing, which claimed to invest in health care start-ups. The firm said it would provide sales, operations, and management expertise to the startups, which it referred to as “portfolio companies,” in order to help them bring their products to market and generate returns for Downing investors.

Downing investors also worked for the firm and were known as employee-investors, and had to make a required investment of between $150,000 and $250,000 in Downing. However, according to the indictment, once the employee-investors made their investment, they quickly learned that Downing did not have access to millions of dollars in funding, often failed to make payroll, had virtually no products to sell, and that the vast majority of the firm’s funding came from their employee investments.

Never miss a story — sign up for CIO newsletters to stay up-to-date on the latest institutional investment industry news.

The employee-investments “were solicited through materially false and misleading statements regarding, among other things, Downing’s use of investor proceeds, sources of funding, financial condition, and ability to pay salaries to employee-investors, and portfolio companies,” the indictment said.

According to the charges, Wagner and Lawrence also began recruiting employee-investors into a new company called Cliniflow Technologies LLC in 2016 after several employee-investors had brought lawsuits against them and several Downing entities. The indictment said the two also made materially false and misleading statements about Cliniflow’s cash reserves, portfolio companies, and exposure to litigation.

“In fact,” said the indictment, “Cliniflow purportedly held majority ownership in the same primary portfolio company as other Downing entities and was simply a new name used by Wagner and Lawrence to solicit investments from new employee-investors that was not tainted by the lawsuits filed against Downing.”

Wagner had pleaded guilty to two counts of securities fraud and one count of wire fraud. In addition to the six-year prison term he received, Wagner was ordered to serve three years of supervised release, and to pay forfeiture in the amount of $549,000 and restitution of at least nearly $7.9 million to his victims. Lawrence is scheduled to be sentenced in February.

Related Stories:

President of Purported VC Firm Pleads Guilty to Securities, Wire Fraud

NYC Investment Fund Manager Convicted of Multiple Fraud Charges

Former Cyberfraud Prevention Firm CEO Arrested for Fraud

Tags: , , , , , ,

«