(September 25, 2013) — Investors
should measure results on what they need and recognize the institutional
investor framework works, according to three of the world’s most experienced
CIOS experienced
CIOs.
Chris Ailman, CIO of the California
State Teachers’ Retirement System, Bob
Maynard, CIO of the Public Employee Retirement System of Idaho, and Adriaan
Ryder, CIO of the QIC,
spoke to attendees at the Hermes Investment Conference in London yesterday.
All three are members of the coveted 300
Club, a group of leading investment professionals from across the globe.
“We’ve lost historical perspective,” Ailman
said. “We have gotten into the mind-set of measuring quarterly performance,
which is taking away our view of the long term.”
“As an investor, when you are looking at sustainability and governance
of companies, you have to look at the long term. These things matter. But when
you’re referring just to quarterly earnings, company CEOs will cut corners.”
Maynard said he was “bored, but nervous” about the current
state of the financial world, but urged investors not to throw the baby out
with the bathwater when trying to mend the system.
“We don’t need a new framework,” he said. “Or at least not
until we find something that works as well as the last one. The numbers we used
were for long-term investment—and if we look through to the 1900s, that’s
long-term enough.”
He said investors were fooled by the calmness of the 1990s,
whereas the volatility witnessed over the past 10 years was more normal.
“What was the annualised standard deviation we used—10% to
13%? We got about 11%. And the annualised real return rate—4% to 6%? We got
around that too. We expected—or we should have expected this.
“You might be down 20% one year, but it rebalances and it
gives you a base to work from.”
Ryder at QIC told investors to look after their own
business, before comparing it with that of their peers.
“We need discussion around objectives, rather than peer
measurement,” he said. “We need to manage all risks, both in our assets and
liabilities.”
Ryder said investors needed to be given the flexibility to
manage their portfolios by setting a range within which they could move
allocations to certain asset classes.
“This way investors can take advantage of crises; they can
be opportunistic and tactical,” he said.
Related content: The
Power 100