Are Latin American Markets Undervalued?

Here’s why one investor thinks they are posed for a revival.



The last decade has been a rough one for Latin American markets. The Latin American MSCI index has consistently underperformed the general MSCI emerging markets index since 2014. The gross domestic product of Brazil, Latin America’s largest economy, grew just 0.27% on average annually between 2011 and 2020. Massive turmoil in Venezuela left bond markets ricocheting up and down in 2019. And the pandemic, combined with the messy politics in many parts of the region, has left some investors even more pessimistic. But it’s not all bad news.

“What we’ve seen over the last couple quarters is that Latin America has gone back into the investment discussion,” says Will Landers, head of Latin American equities at BTG Pactual Asset Management.

The MSCI Latin America index shows that the region is one of the few to have positive growth in the first quarter of 2022. In fact, they had a 26.1% gain as measured by the MSCI Latin America ETF. Aggressive monetary policy in the past year in countries such as Brazil, Chile and Mexico have also led investors to believe that these countries may be quicker to recover from inflation compared to the United States and Europe, which are only just starting to enact rate hikes.

“Most of the central banks in the region have already done a lot of the heavy lifting to bring rates back into positive territory,” says Landers.

Want the latest institutional investment industry
news and insights? Sign up for CIO newsletters.

Landers thinks that because of this, Brazil has some undervalued equities that are particularly good buys right now.

“I think we can look forward to rate reductions in Brazil sometime in the middle of next year,” says Landers. “Once that happens, I think the consumer discretionary stocks, which had been a favorite of many investors in the past, will come back.”

Landers is also optimistic about Mexico, especially as more investors and businesses set up shop in the country because of its easy access to the United States.

“We like parts of Mexico, especially the ones related to exports and nearshoring,” says Landers. “A lot of companies in Asia are bringing production capacity to Mexico because it is closer to the United States and easier to trade with the United States there.”

Another country with many potentially undervalued investment opportunities is Chile, according to Landers.

“The market is trading very cheap compared to its historical average despite the fact that I think region-specific risks are lower than they have been on average for the last decade,” he says.

Chile is a major producer of iron, ore, copper and lithium.

“There’s not a lot of places where you can get that stuff in a competitive way,” says Landers.

However, there are still countries in the region that Landers shies away from.

“We’re staying away from Colombia and Peru,” says Landers. “They are not very liquid markets, and there are currently too many political uncertainties in those countries.”

Related Stories:

The Future of Emerging Markets Amid a War and a Pandemic

New Mexico Pension Posts Highest Returns in 36 Years

Chile Rejects Two Pension Withdrawal Proposals

Tags: , , , , , , , ,

GOP-Led States Ban Pension Plans From Dealing With ESG-Backing Firms

Texas probes whether BlackRock and other asset managers are boycotting fossil fuels.

Environmental, social and governance precepts are popular among some U.S. institutional investors, particularly university endowments. But now a backlash is developing in Republican-led state governments, particularly from fossil-fuel-producing locales.

In Texas, West Virginia and Kentucky, legislatures have required state funds to limit transactions with companies that divest oil, natural gas and coal, according to news reports. West Virginia’s and Arkansas’ treasurers have recently pulled out state account money from BlackRock, whose chief has been vocal about fighting climate change.

In Texas, a new law prevents state agencies from doing business with companies that the state comptroller determines are “boycotting” fossil fuels. It’s unclear how much fossil fuel stock the state’s retirement programs hold, as is the extent of their dealings with firms following ESG precepts.

Want the latest institutional investment industry
news and insights? Sign up for CIO newsletters.

Texas Comptroller Glenn Hegar sent a letter to 19 financial firms, including BlackRock, JPMorgan Chase and Wells Fargo, inquiring about their fossil fuel divestiture practices. “Our research thus far shows that some companies are telling us and other energy-producing states one thing, and then turning around and telling their liberal clients in other states another thing,” Hegar said in a press release.

The firms replied that they don’t boycott fossil fuels, a Reuters report indicates. BlackRock, for instance, said its fiduciary duty requires that it not avoid any classes of stocks, although it added that the firm also backs projects aimed at lowering greenhouse gas emissions.

BlackRock reported that it manages $24 billion for Texas public pension plans, and invests in $8.3 billion of private projects in the state, such as a natural gas utility and a carbon capture pipeline system.

The firm’s CEO, Larry Fink, has urged fellow corporate chiefs to push for ESG initiatives. Last spring, BlackRock backed three dissident directors seeking election to ExxonMobil’s board who wanted to fight the oil giant’s reluctance to move into renewable energy.

Since Texas passed its bill last year, at least seven other states have either considered or passed similar legislation. Last fall, a consortium of 15 treasurers from mainly GOP-led states published a letter declaring they would no longer bank with financial firms that were “boycotting” fossil fuels.

Idaho passed a law in March barring investment of state funds in companies that prioritize commitments to ESG over returns.

In April, at the Utah Republican Party’s convention, thousands of attendees cheered when Senator Mike Lee compared green investments to critical race theory—another term conservatives tie to liberal folly: “Between CRT and ESG and MSNBC, we get way too much B.S.,” Lee said.

Related Stories:

Idaho Bills Aim to Curb Public ESG Investing

ESG Will Power Capitalism to Solve Humanity’s Problems, Says Ackman

Big Oil Strikes Back at ESG

Correction: We incorrenctly reported that West Virginia and Arkansas had yanked state pension money from BlackRock, and have rectified the error.

Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

«