Not Such a Small World After All, CIOs Say

Stefan Strein, CIO at the Cleveland Clinic, during a panel discussion at CIO’s 2022 Influential Investors Forum, said deglobalization is his primary geopolitical concern because of its potential to reverse gains made in the battle against inflation.

Deglobalization “touches every facet of the economy,” Strein said. “It’s going to be really interesting over the next couple of years, especially as we deglobalize and potentially fragment into various factions around the world.”

The potential for deglobalization, stemming from the Russia-Ukraine war, U.S.-China tensions and China’s political and economic trends, were among other top geopolitical issues asset allocators mentioned as having a potential impact on portfolios.

For more stories like this, sign up for the CIO Alert newsletter. 

Amidst pressure to deglobalize, countering inflation remains a priority throughout global markets. Jeremy Wolfson, CIO of the $20 billion Los Angeles Water and Power Employees’ Retirement Plan, highlighted that the low-inflation environment that defined the U.S. economy from the mid-1980s through 2007 featured a straight line of increasing globalization.

Over the past decades, “we got to a point of hyper-globalization,” Wolfson said. “If you look at import-and-export prices as a percentage of GDP, they’re starting to plateau and roll over. Those trends [signaling increased deglobalization] are obviously challenging institutional investors. We’re coming out of that hyper-globalization trend that we’ve seen for some time.”

The Russia-Ukraine war prompted many questions about energy and security in the West.

In reference to divesture of Russian securities in institutional portfolios after the invasion of the Ukraine, Wolfson said, “[as a public plan, the first step] was disclosure. Thankfully, we had already positioned ourselves a little bit out of the space when all this kind of came about. We did have to write a little off, and we provided information to the city council’s office. Our board really looked at their fiduciary responsibility, and at the end of the day, they took that to heart, so they told the mayor, and the council, that we’re very responsible, that we understand social issues and that it’s a human tragedy.”

At the focal point of geopolitical security is energy security, as highlighted by the Russian invasion of Ukraine. A move toward renewables and the revolutionization of world auto fleets provide avenues toward energy security.

Strein pointed out that limiting carbon output by increasing the use of electric vehicles requires cooperation among economic regions.

“Minerals for battery technologies are quite dispersed, though most of the production is done in China,” Strein said. “Unless we all are going to be driving Chinese cars in the next 20 years, we have to figure out a way to get some of these metals processed here in the United States or North America.”

U.S.-China relations are another important part of any conversation about deglobalization.

Jonathan Glidden, managing director of pensions at Delta Air Lines, which sponsors a currently frozen, but fully funded $16 billion defined-benefit plan, in addition to a $26 billion 401(k) plan, provided perspective on how different the business relationship between the U.S. and China has been since its 2001 membership in the World Trade Organization.

The evolution of China, economically and politically, has considerable influence on businesses throughout the world, Wolfson described.

“It used to be that China was run by nine people; now it is really just run by [Xi Jinping, general secretary of the Chinese Communist Party],” Wolfson said. “They tried to convert themselves into a consumption economy, going from a more export-related economy, but their emerging salaries are [now] at the top of the emerging environment. It is not as cheap as it was to produce in China as it used to be.”

Related Stories:

The Trade Mess Is Improved, But Don’t Get Too Comfortable

Institutional Investors Take a Cautious, Long-Term Approach to Emerging Markets

Will US Allocators Stay the Course on Chinese Investments?

Tags: deglobalization, geopolitical, geopolitical risk, Jeremy Wolfson, Jonathan Glidden, Stefan Stein

The Ontario Teachers’ Pension Plan Board has named Anna Murray global head of sustainable investing and senior managing director.

The C$242.5 billion ($178.6 billion) pension fund has tasked Murray, who started on December 5, with executing Ontario Teachers’ climate strategy, corporate governance activities including proxy voting and public company engagements and overseeing its approach to impact investing.

The pension fund pledged in early 2021 to become net-zero in carbon emissions by 2050. Murray will also oversee corporate governance activities, including proxy voting and public company engagements, as well as the integration and assessment of environmental, social and governance investments within the pension fund’s portfolio.

Murray joins Ontario Teachers’ from Sun Life Capital Management, where she was global head of ESG and was responsible for integrating ESG risk management and value creation practices into investment decisions and management. She was also global head of ESG at BentallGreenOak, SLC Management’s real estate investment manager.

Want the latest institutional investment industry news and insights? Sign up for CIO newsletters. 

She is also co-chair of the United Nations’ Principles for Responsible Investment’s real estate advisory committee and co-chair of the environmental committee at the Pension Real Estate Association. Additionally, she is on the board of directors for the Responsible Investment Association and the Canada Green Building Council.

Ontario Teachers’ reported earlier this year that it invested more than C$3 billion in green assets in 2021, including acquiring from NextEra Energy Resources a 50% stake in a portfolio of 13 wind, solar and energy storage assets in the U.S. The organization is also looking to increase its green investments to C$50 billion from approximately C$33 billion.

“Sustainable investing is a key part of Ontario Teachers’ strategy as it generates positive, real-world impacts while supporting long-term value creation for our members,” Ziad Hindo, Ontario Teachers’ chief investment officer, said in a statement. “We look forward to Ms. Murray and her team helping us meet our impact-related commitments, as well as continu[ing] to evolve our approach and build on our leadership in sustainable investing.”